Written by Kathy Wheatley on
 March 10, 2025

Thomas Markle critiques Meghan's authenticity in new Netflix show

Thomas Markle recently voiced criticism regarding his daughter Meghan Markle's presence and authenticity on her new Netflix cooking show, "With Love, Meghan."

According to GB News, His remarks underscore his belief that Meghan's on-camera persona lacks spontaneity, using rehearsals to perfect her expressions.

Thomas made these observations after watching several clips from the show, though he admitted to not having seen the entire series yet. With his background in Hollywood, he feels equipped to judge the nuances of on-camera performance. Thomas Markle's career included stints on TV shows like "Married With Children" and "General Hospital," giving him insight into what makes or breaks a TV personality.

According to Thomas, the best cooking shows are those where the host's passion and authenticity shine through. He commented on the necessity for a cooking show presenter to engage the audience with genuine enthusiasm and natural interactions.

Thomas Markle's Opinion on Successful Cooking Shows

In his critique, Thomas expressed concerns about Meghan's approach, which he views as overly calculated. "Everything she says is pre-planned and rehearsed. She tries so hard to be perfect," he remarked in an interview with the Mail. This striving for perfection, he argues, detracts from her ability to appear relatable and spontaneous on screen.

He even specifically pointed out moments when he feels Meghan is not being herself. "I know when she's faking it for the cameras. She's trying so hard to be perfect that she tenses up every time the camera is on her," he added. This criticism highlights a disconnect between Meghan's television persona and the relaxed, engaging presence needed to captivate a cooking show audience.

Industry Speculations Regarding Future Contracts

Thomas also noted that new episodes of "With Love, Meghan" are expected to release this summer, with her five-year deal with Netflix set to expire in October. This timeline brings additional scrutiny as some industry insiders speculate about the future of the Sussexes' contract with Netflix. There's a prevailing sense of uncertainty whether the streaming service will renew the contract.

Overall, Thomas's remarks paint a picture of a father who feels estranged from his daughter's current lifestyle and public image. His insights into the entertainment industry lend some weight to his criticisms, suggesting a blend of personal disappointment and professional critique.

Father’s Discontent with Hollywood Stardom

Amid these observations, Thomas hinted at his reservations about watching the entire series. "I might sit down and watch it one day but I'm not sure," he said uncertainly, suggesting a complex relationship with his daughter's work. His reluctance maybe as much about the content as it is about the strained father-daughter relationship.

His detailed feedback on what makes a cooking show host successful involves a combination of humor, humanity, and involvement in the cooking process itself. "When you are stuffing the turkey's a*** it has to look like you're having fun doing it," he explained, indicating his view on the necessity for authenticity and enjoyment in hosting.

Meghan's Approach Critiqued by Family

These opinions from a family member open a window into personal dynamics that go beyond the public's usual view of celebrity and show business. They underscore the challenges Meghan faces in balancing her public persona with private expectations and the scrutiny that follows her steps in the public eye.

As the future of Meghan's ventures with Netflix hangs in the balance, the entertainment community and her audience will be closely watching to see if she adjusts her approach in response to feedback like that of her father's, or if she continues on the same path, refining her on-screen persona against the odds.

In essence, Thomas Markle's observations are not just about a father's view of his daughter's career but also about the wider issues of authenticity and performance in the age of reality TV and celebrity culture. Whether these insights prompt a change in Meghan's television approach or confirm the complexities of her public role remains to be seen.

Author Image

About Kathy Wheatley

Your trusted source for independent, comprehensive entertainment news.
© 2025 - Insider Journal - All rights reserved
Privacy Policy
magnifier