Written by Kathy Wheatley on
 November 9, 2024

Andrew Stewart Disputes Martha Stewart's Infidelity Accusations In New Documentary

In a surprising twist, Andrew Stewart, Martha Stewart's ex-husband, has spoken out against allegations of infidelity made by Martha in her recent Netflix documentary titled "Martha."

Released on October 25, the film has ignited controversy between the former couple, prompting Andrew and his current wife, Shyla Nelson Stewart, to publicly defend their side, E! Online reported.

Martha Stewart’s Candid Documentary Release

On October 25, Martha Stewart released a deeply personal Netflix documentary that explores various aspects of her life, including her marriage to Andrew Stewart. In the documentary, *Martha,* Martha shares her perspective on their years together, specifically accusing Andrew of infidelity with her assistant—an event she claims happened at their Connecticut home.

The couple ended their marriage in 1990, but these allegations have reignited public interest in their personal lives. Andrew went on to marry the assistant, Robyn Fairclough, in 1993, though their marriage ultimately ended in separation.

Andrew and Shyla Stewart’s Response and Defense

On October 12, Andrew Stewart and his wife, Shyla Nelson Stewart, expressed their dismay on Facebook over the documentary’s content and portrayal of past events. They described their current life together as one of gratitude and love, highlighting the joy and peace they have found in each other over the past nine years.

Shyla Nelson Stewart voiced her frustration with the documentary's "sensationalized" approach, saying it wrongly revisits and dramatizes past disputes for public entertainment. She criticized the documentary for reopening old wounds that those directly involved had long since healed.

The Stewarts' Plea for Peace

In their Facebook post, Andrew and Shyla shared a sentiment of love and forgiveness, even extending well wishes to Martha herself. They expressed a desire for her to experience the same kind of profound love and peace they have come to know in their life together. Shyla further acknowledged the difficult times Andrew experienced in his former marriage, describing it as "painful and abusive" but emphasized his effort to move beyond those darker times.

The couple highlighted their commitment to their family, which includes five adult children and three grandchildren, underscoring their dedication to providing a nurturing and positive environment, far removed from the controversies of the past.

Martha Stewart’s Revelations and Confessions

In her documentary, Martha Stewart did not hold back on her confessions, admitting to a brief affair with an Irish man during her extended honeymoon in Europe and even describing an emotionally charged encounter that led to a kiss with another man. Stewart’s candid confessions are part of what she described as an emotional and tumultuous period in her younger years.

Martha's commentary in the documentary also included advice directed at young women, using her experiences to caution them about the signs of a cheating partner, reflecting her resolve and the lessons she has learned from her marriage.

Public and Media Reaction to the Documentary

E! News and other media outlets have reached out to representatives for Martha and Andrew Stewart for further comments, though neither has responded to inquiries as of now. The documentary has sparked discussions about the complexities of personal relationships and the impact of their public airing on all involved parties.

The controversy sheds light on the different paths the Stewarts have taken since their divorce, with Martha becoming a media mogul and lifestyle queen, and Andrew finding solace in a quieter, more grounded life away from the limelight.

As viewers and fans process the revelations from the documentary, the discourse around personal history, truth, and reconciliation continues to evolve, highlighting the deep emotional layers involved in the marriages and personal relationships of public figures.

Author Image

About Kathy Wheatley

NewsLetter

Like Gossip?

Get the latest gossip and celebrity news straight to your inbox. choose the newsletters that are right for you. 
Sign up >
Your trusted source for independent, comprehensive entertainment news.
© 2024 - Insider Journal - All rights reserved
Privacy Policy
magnifier